Hurricanes Were and Remain Political
Posted by Darin Hayton on 10/30 at 04:12 PM
Various efforts to interpret Hurricane Sandy and to consider its political significance prompted me to look back at some early accounts of hurricanes. By the early 17th century reports of terrifying storms in the New World that lasted days and devastated large areas started appearing in the Europe. Frequently, these accounts were short, dramatic pamphlets intended to do much more than just report on a new type of storm. By the end of the century, some writers had begun describing storms in Europe as hurricanes, typically to advance some political agenda or some religious ideology (a quick search of the Philosophical Transactions didn’t turn up any articles on hurricanes until well into the 18th century).
One of the early reports on hurricanes came from John Taylor, domestic adventurer, poet, propagandist, Royalist, and sometime overseer of the Company of Watermen in London. In 1638 he seems to have published New and Strange News from St. Christophers, of a tempestuous Spirit, which is called by the Indians a Hurry Cano, which happeneth in many of those Islands of America, or the West-Indies, as it did in August last the 5. 1638. Blowing downe houses, tearing up trees by the rootes, and it did puffe men up from the earth, as they had beene Feathers, killing divers men.
Taylor considers hurricanes a form of divine punishment or “severe Justice” intended not just to punish sinners but to bring heathens and the barbarous to a state of “Civility and Christian Liberty.” Taylor holds up Alexander the Great up as a sort of human example of how good can come from apparent evil. Although Alexander had conquered and subjugated many nations, in the process he had taught them
to build Townes, Cities, and defencible places, to apparell their naked bodies, in their thraldome they found Religion: and whereas in their Freedomes they did use to kill their aged Parents inhumanely, to eate them with savadge, ravenous, most greedy Gormandizing, by Servitude they learned more reverend Duty; they were taught the Rites aud Lawes of Matrimony: And whereas in their licentious freedome, they bedded with their Mothers, Sisters, Daughters, and Neeces, not sparing any Kindred, Aliance, Propinquity, or any degree of blood or consanguinity, they by Servitude learned better life and manners; and also by being conquer’d and overcome, they were taught the use of Armes, the practice of Arts, and the laudable Experience of Tillage and Husbandry.
For Taylor, hurricanes served a similar purpose of civilizing “Heathens, Indians, and barbarous Nations unconverted: as for the knowne Examples in America, and in divers Islands adjacent, where this Hurri Cano is frequent.” Hurricanes were God’s mechanism for converting New World inhabitants to Christianity.
Taylor doesn’t know the origins of the name—“but the Indians doe call it Hurri Cano, or Hurri Caenae, or Cani”—or what causes hurricanes, though he reports that some consider it a violent spirit accompanied by lightning, thunder, and strong winds. Despite not knowing what caused hurricanes, these same Indians had developed an precise and proven way to predict hurricanes:
hey doe observe that just so many daies as it will be before the Hurri Cano doth come, so many Circles will bee as it were fringed and gleaming about the Moone: as if it bee but one day before it come, then there will be but one Circle; if two Circles, then it wil be two daies; and so perhaps three or foure Circles, as it did lately at Saint Christophers, where it came in that fearefull and unresistable fury, on the fifth day of August last, 1638.
The Indians had tried to warn the English and Dutch, but the storm was so fierce that many houses and five ships were destroyed and 70 people were drowned. According to Taylor, hurricanes were always destructive, tossing people about like they were feathers, overturning houses, and toppling trees. People seek refuge in caves and pits and holes, taking with them anything they hope to save. Taylor was particularly taken by a type of hammock the Indians had developed to survive the hurricanes:
They doe likewise tye or make fast Hamackoes or hanging Cabin unto two Trees that are lopy’d, and then the people do get into those Cabins, & so they do lye downe in them, being hang’d above the ground sixe or seaven foot, eyther with strong Ropes or iron chaines; and so they swing two and againe like a Bell when it is rung, when this tempest is; their Hamackoes are made either of course linning cloath, or of strong stuffe made of twisted threads spun out of the rindes of trees;
Taylor was convinced that hurricanes were God’s efforts to improve the world, and he wanted his readers to reach the same conclusion. He ends with a story about how the island of Bermuda was discovered. In 1609, Sir George Sommers set out with Sir Thomas Gates and a fleet of eight ships sailed for Virginia. When the fleet was caught in a hurricane Sommers’s ship was separated from the rest and driven onto the rocks on Bermuda. Sommers crew survived and went ashore where they found a fruitful island. Over the next 10 months they lived on the island, felled timber, and constructed a new ship. They then set out for Virginia where Gates and the rest rejoiced in seeing Sommers alive. This story, Taylor reminds his reader, is “proofe of Gods mercy and power, in drawing good out of Evill.”
In the 1670s during the Franco-Dutch conflict, in which England supported the Dutch cause, hurricanes helped explain disasters in the war. More than one pamphlet or broadsheet published in England claimed that hurricanes had ravaged Amsterdam and destroyed reformed churches and buildings in the city. In most cases, the pamphlet claimed to be a translation of a Dutch publication. These pamphlets offer a chance to see how apparently natural phenomena were enlisted in war-time efforts to generate support for the Dutch or attack the French.
Natural phenomena are still enlisted in moral, religious, and political agendas, as any search for the terms “hurricane” “sandy” and “god” or as the row between Governor Christie and Mayor Langford reveals. Whether understood as God’s punishments or opportunities to decry bad governance, hurricanes and other natural disasters are as politically important today as they ever have been.